diff --git a/worlds/pokemon_emerald/__init__.py b/worlds/pokemon_emerald/__init__.py
index 4f2c2ef95c..10abed539f 100644
--- a/worlds/pokemon_emerald/__init__.py
+++ b/worlds/pokemon_emerald/__init__.py
@@ -123,6 +123,7 @@ class PokemonEmeraldWorld(World):
     blacklisted_wilds: Set[int]
     blacklisted_starters: Set[int]
     blacklisted_opponent_pokemon: Set[int]
+    allowed_dexsanity_species: set[int]
     hm_requirements: Dict[str, Union[int, List[str]]]
     auth: bytes
 
@@ -142,6 +143,7 @@ class PokemonEmeraldWorld(World):
         self.blacklisted_wilds = set()
         self.blacklisted_starters = set()
         self.blacklisted_opponent_pokemon = set()
+        self.allowed_dexsanity_species = set()
         self.modified_maps = copy.deepcopy(emerald_data.maps)
         self.modified_species = copy.deepcopy(emerald_data.species)
         self.modified_tmhm_moves = []
@@ -265,6 +267,7 @@ class PokemonEmeraldWorld(World):
         from .regions import create_regions
         all_regions = create_regions(self)
 
+        randomize_wild_encounters(self)
         # Categories with progression items always included
         categories = {
             LocationCategory.BADGE,
@@ -494,7 +497,6 @@ class PokemonEmeraldWorld(World):
         set_rules(self)
 
     def connect_entrances(self):
-        randomize_wild_encounters(self)
         self.shuffle_badges_hms()
         # For entrance randomization, disconnect entrances here, randomize map, then
         # undo badge/HM placement and re-shuffle them in the new map.
diff --git a/worlds/pokemon_emerald/locations.py b/worlds/pokemon_emerald/locations.py
index 49ce147041..fd8d0ebc7d 100644
--- a/worlds/pokemon_emerald/locations.py
+++ b/worlds/pokemon_emerald/locations.py
@@ -110,7 +110,7 @@ def create_locations_by_category(world: "PokemonEmeraldWorld", regions: Dict[str
                 national_dex_id = int(location_name[-3:])  # Location names are formatted POKEDEX_REWARD_###
 
                 # Don't create this pokedex location if player can't find it in the wild
-                if NATIONAL_ID_TO_SPECIES_ID[national_dex_id] in world.blacklisted_wilds:
+                if NATIONAL_ID_TO_SPECIES_ID[national_dex_id] in world.blacklisted_wilds or NATIONAL_ID_TO_SPECIES_ID[national_dex_id] not in world.allowed_dexsanity_species:
                     continue
 
                 location_id += POKEDEX_OFFSET + national_dex_id
diff --git a/worlds/pokemon_emerald/options.py b/worlds/pokemon_emerald/options.py
index 29929bd672..9529be877e 100644
--- a/worlds/pokemon_emerald/options.py
+++ b/worlds/pokemon_emerald/options.py
@@ -4,7 +4,7 @@ Option definitions for Pokemon Emerald
 from dataclasses import dataclass
 
 from Options import (Choice, DeathLink, DefaultOnToggle, OptionSet, NamedRange, Range, Toggle, FreeText,
-                     PerGameCommonOptions, OptionGroup, StartInventory)
+                     PerGameCommonOptions, OptionGroup, StartInventory, OptionList)
 
 from .data import data
 
@@ -129,6 +129,17 @@ class Dexsanity(Toggle):
     display_name = "Dexsanity"
 
 
+class DexsanityEncounterTypes(OptionList):
+    """
+    Determines which Dexsanity encounter areas are in logic.
+
+    Logic will only consider access to Pokemon at these encounter types, but they may still be found elsewhere.
+    """
+    display_name = "Dexsanity Encounter Types"
+    valid_keys = {"Land", "Water", "Fishing"}
+    default = valid_keys.copy()
+
+
 class Trainersanity(Toggle):
     """
     Defeating a trainer gives you an item.
@@ -870,6 +881,7 @@ class PokemonEmeraldOptions(PerGameCommonOptions):
     npc_gifts: RandomizeNpcGifts
     berry_trees: RandomizeBerryTrees
     dexsanity: Dexsanity
+    dexsanity_encounter_types: DexsanityEncounterTypes
     trainersanity: Trainersanity
     item_pool_type: ItemPoolType
 
diff --git a/worlds/pokemon_emerald/pokemon.py b/worlds/pokemon_emerald/pokemon.py
index 8f799ce611..73af6c4658 100644
--- a/worlds/pokemon_emerald/pokemon.py
+++ b/worlds/pokemon_emerald/pokemon.py
@@ -264,6 +264,12 @@ def _rename_wild_events(world: "PokemonEmeraldWorld", map_data: MapData, new_slo
 
 
 def randomize_wild_encounters(world: "PokemonEmeraldWorld") -> None:
+    encounter_table = {
+        "Land": EncounterType.LAND,
+        "Water": EncounterType.WATER,
+        "Fishing": EncounterType.FISHING,
+    }
+    enabled_encounters = {encounter_table[encounter_type] for encounter_type in world.options.dexsanity_encounter_types.value}
     if world.options.wild_pokemon == RandomizeWildPokemon.option_vanilla:
         return
 
@@ -370,6 +376,8 @@ def randomize_wild_encounters(world: "PokemonEmeraldWorld") -> None:
 
             # Actually create the new list of slots and encounter table
             new_slots: List[int] = []
+            if encounter_type in enabled_encounters:
+                world.allowed_dexsanity_species.update(table.slots)
             for species_id in table.slots:
                 new_slots.append(species_old_to_new_map[species_id])
 
diff --git a/worlds/pokemon_emerald/rules.py b/worlds/pokemon_emerald/rules.py
index 828eb20f72..eeadb8bea2 100644
--- a/worlds/pokemon_emerald/rules.py
+++ b/worlds/pokemon_emerald/rules.py
@@ -1548,7 +1548,7 @@ def set_rules(world: "PokemonEmeraldWorld") -> None:
         for i in range(NUM_REAL_SPECIES):
             species = data.species[NATIONAL_ID_TO_SPECIES_ID[i + 1]]
 
-            if species.species_id in world.blacklisted_wilds:
+            if species.species_id in world.blacklisted_wilds or species.species_id not in world.allowed_dexsanity_species:
                 continue
 
             set_rule(